• Home
    • Test Your Farm Smarts
  • Local Affiliates
    • Whatcom Family Farmers
    • Yakima Family Farmers
    • Skagit Family Farmers >
      • Imported Elk Threaten
      • Skagit Farming
      • Skagit Water Access
      • Hirst Fix Except Skagit
      • Rep Rick Larsen
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction: what they say
        • Jurisdiction Contacts
        • Jurisdiction Poster
        • SITC Jurisdiction Documents
        • WA Farm Bureau Letter
  • Contribute
  • Issues
    • 2019 Legislative Appeal
    • Raspberry Import Crisis >
      • Consumer Information
    • Protecting Farmworkers >
      • L&I Record Fine Out of Line
    • Litigation Industry vs Dairies >
      • Letter to WELC
      • Nitrates and Human Health
    • Death of Dairies >
      • Rural Community Protection
    • Orca & Chinook Recovery >
      • Why the Orca Plan Fails
      • Chinook dogged by dogma
      • Real Solutions for Chinook
    • Puget Soundkeeper's Harm >
      • Puget Soundkeeper Donor Appeal
      • Puget Soundkeeper is Wrong
      • Puget Soundkeeper continues anti-farm propaganda
      • PSKA's Fundraising Litigation
      • PSKA "Hot Air" on Emissions
    • PSNERP
    • What's Upstream Attack >
      • EPA remembers What's Upstream
      • Why We Object
      • Facts on What's Upstream >
        • EPA Supports Illegal Campaign
        • Dairy Farm Economics
        • About Buffers
        • Voters & Farmers
        • What's With Whatsupstream? >
          • What's With... PDF
      • PDC Complaint
      • EPA Funding Timeline
      • EPA Funding Documents
    • Farm Regulation Facts >
      • Regulation Documents
      • Thank Family Farmers
    • Dairies & Water Quality >
      • EPA's Falsified Science
      • Other End Video
      • Do Manure Lagoons Pollute?
      • Enviro Stewardship
      • Thanks for Protecting Water
      • Wash Dairy Facts
    • Good News about Buffers
    • Puget Sound Partnership
    • Skagit Watershed
    • Document Library >
      • PSP Action Agenda
    • Discussion
    • Yesterday's Issues >
      • Pesticide Farm Killing Bill
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction Poster
      • Hirst & Foster Fix
      • Regulatory Abuse
  • What's New
    • Our Blog
    • Our Podcast >
      • Soundcloud
      • iTunes
    • Press >
      • Latest News >
        • Hearings Board Rejects PSA Claims
        • Royal Dairy Sustainability Award
      • Press Statements
      • Press Reports >
        • Larry Stap on KOMO
        • Evergreen Press
        • Press Chinook Predation
        • Dairy Press Reports
        • Berry Crisis Reports
        • Media Reports (internal)
      • Fact Check >
        • Fact Check: WSJ on Dairies
      • KOMO report debunked
      • EPA Document Request
  • About
    • Q & A SFF
    • How You Can Help
    • Contact Our Representatives
    • Contact
    • Meet our Farmers
    • Farm Smart 1 Answers
  • CAFO Ruling Press
Save Family Farming
  • Home
    • Test Your Farm Smarts
  • Local Affiliates
    • Whatcom Family Farmers
    • Yakima Family Farmers
    • Skagit Family Farmers >
      • Imported Elk Threaten
      • Skagit Farming
      • Skagit Water Access
      • Hirst Fix Except Skagit
      • Rep Rick Larsen
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction: what they say
        • Jurisdiction Contacts
        • Jurisdiction Poster
        • SITC Jurisdiction Documents
        • WA Farm Bureau Letter
  • Contribute
  • Issues
    • 2019 Legislative Appeal
    • Raspberry Import Crisis >
      • Consumer Information
    • Protecting Farmworkers >
      • L&I Record Fine Out of Line
    • Litigation Industry vs Dairies >
      • Letter to WELC
      • Nitrates and Human Health
    • Death of Dairies >
      • Rural Community Protection
    • Orca & Chinook Recovery >
      • Why the Orca Plan Fails
      • Chinook dogged by dogma
      • Real Solutions for Chinook
    • Puget Soundkeeper's Harm >
      • Puget Soundkeeper Donor Appeal
      • Puget Soundkeeper is Wrong
      • Puget Soundkeeper continues anti-farm propaganda
      • PSKA's Fundraising Litigation
      • PSKA "Hot Air" on Emissions
    • PSNERP
    • What's Upstream Attack >
      • EPA remembers What's Upstream
      • Why We Object
      • Facts on What's Upstream >
        • EPA Supports Illegal Campaign
        • Dairy Farm Economics
        • About Buffers
        • Voters & Farmers
        • What's With Whatsupstream? >
          • What's With... PDF
      • PDC Complaint
      • EPA Funding Timeline
      • EPA Funding Documents
    • Farm Regulation Facts >
      • Regulation Documents
      • Thank Family Farmers
    • Dairies & Water Quality >
      • EPA's Falsified Science
      • Other End Video
      • Do Manure Lagoons Pollute?
      • Enviro Stewardship
      • Thanks for Protecting Water
      • Wash Dairy Facts
    • Good News about Buffers
    • Puget Sound Partnership
    • Skagit Watershed
    • Document Library >
      • PSP Action Agenda
    • Discussion
    • Yesterday's Issues >
      • Pesticide Farm Killing Bill
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction Poster
      • Hirst & Foster Fix
      • Regulatory Abuse
  • What's New
    • Our Blog
    • Our Podcast >
      • Soundcloud
      • iTunes
    • Press >
      • Latest News >
        • Hearings Board Rejects PSA Claims
        • Royal Dairy Sustainability Award
      • Press Statements
      • Press Reports >
        • Larry Stap on KOMO
        • Evergreen Press
        • Press Chinook Predation
        • Dairy Press Reports
        • Berry Crisis Reports
        • Media Reports (internal)
      • Fact Check >
        • Fact Check: WSJ on Dairies
      • KOMO report debunked
      • EPA Document Request
  • About
    • Q & A SFF
    • How You Can Help
    • Contact Our Representatives
    • Contact
    • Meet our Farmers
    • Farm Smart 1 Answers
  • CAFO Ruling Press

The latest from
​Save Family Farming

Notes, thoughts and interesting news items. 

Outgoing EPA Director doesn't understand why EPA has such a bad name among farmers

1/5/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture

Outgoing EPA Director Gina McCarthy explains in this interview with the Washington Post that "science is fundamental to everything we do."

Really?

The Director said: "Science is everything. Almost every action we take is bounded by what the science tells us. It’s based on a factual record of where the world is today and what is our obligation under our mission. Science needs to be protected. Any effort to undermine that science in a way that would give undue influence to folks that aren’t scientists is a really big problem."

Not in Region 10 where EPA staff ran roughshod over science in number of examples in their dealing with farmers. We will provide more details of the disregard for scientific procedures demonstrated by the staff and how they dealt with the scientists who called them to task for this.

While we think the Director is out of touch when it comes to how EPA Region 10 dealt with farmers, in her interview she pointed out the failure of EPA to build relationships with farmers as perhaps the greatest failing of her time at the agency. She said:
​"EPA does not have the strong relationships with rural communities that it has with urban communities. We work in a lot of communities, we work on a lot of urban-related issues. We have great relationships with mayors. But we have tended to not be able to have a very compelling rural agenda and to build constituencies there. That’s been challenging for us."

If there is a single symbol of the well established urban-rural divide, it may be Director McCarthy.  It is a vast understatement that the EPA has failed to build a connection to rural communities. The What's Upstream debacle may be the poster child for this, but it is seen in many interactions between EPA staff and farmers. We have heard from a well-placed source that Region 10 has a reputation for being the most antagonistic to farmers of any EPA region. And we are are aware of the what Senator Roberts and Inhofe noted about the reputation of EPA for antagonism to farmers nationally. Maybe a starting place to correct the clear failing of McCarthy and McLerran's leadership is to get the heck out of downtown Seattle and put the region HQ in a more rural environment. 

it's clear the next EPA national director and Region 10 Administrator have their work cut out for them. We don't have much to thank Director McCarthy for, but we can thank her for pointing out this very serious failure of her administration with the hope that the incoming leadership will take notice.

UPDATE: AgInfo's Bob Larson highlights the issue of EPA disconnect from the rural communities in this January 6 edition of the Farm Bureau report:

http://www.aginfo.net/index.cfm/event/report/id/Washington-State-Farm-Bureau-Report-36089


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Save Family Farming

    We're working to build public understanding of the environmental stewardship of our family farmers.

    Archives

    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

join the conversation

  • Home
    • Test Your Farm Smarts
  • Local Affiliates
    • Whatcom Family Farmers
    • Yakima Family Farmers
    • Skagit Family Farmers >
      • Imported Elk Threaten
      • Skagit Farming
      • Skagit Water Access
      • Hirst Fix Except Skagit
      • Rep Rick Larsen
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction: what they say
        • Jurisdiction Contacts
        • Jurisdiction Poster
        • SITC Jurisdiction Documents
        • WA Farm Bureau Letter
  • Contribute
  • Issues
    • 2019 Legislative Appeal
    • Raspberry Import Crisis >
      • Consumer Information
    • Protecting Farmworkers >
      • L&I Record Fine Out of Line
    • Litigation Industry vs Dairies >
      • Letter to WELC
      • Nitrates and Human Health
    • Death of Dairies >
      • Rural Community Protection
    • Orca & Chinook Recovery >
      • Why the Orca Plan Fails
      • Chinook dogged by dogma
      • Real Solutions for Chinook
    • Puget Soundkeeper's Harm >
      • Puget Soundkeeper Donor Appeal
      • Puget Soundkeeper is Wrong
      • Puget Soundkeeper continues anti-farm propaganda
      • PSKA's Fundraising Litigation
      • PSKA "Hot Air" on Emissions
    • PSNERP
    • What's Upstream Attack >
      • EPA remembers What's Upstream
      • Why We Object
      • Facts on What's Upstream >
        • EPA Supports Illegal Campaign
        • Dairy Farm Economics
        • About Buffers
        • Voters & Farmers
        • What's With Whatsupstream? >
          • What's With... PDF
      • PDC Complaint
      • EPA Funding Timeline
      • EPA Funding Documents
    • Farm Regulation Facts >
      • Regulation Documents
      • Thank Family Farmers
    • Dairies & Water Quality >
      • EPA's Falsified Science
      • Other End Video
      • Do Manure Lagoons Pollute?
      • Enviro Stewardship
      • Thanks for Protecting Water
      • Wash Dairy Facts
    • Good News about Buffers
    • Puget Sound Partnership
    • Skagit Watershed
    • Document Library >
      • PSP Action Agenda
    • Discussion
    • Yesterday's Issues >
      • Pesticide Farm Killing Bill
      • Swinomish Jurisdiction Issue >
        • Jurisdiction Poster
      • Hirst & Foster Fix
      • Regulatory Abuse
  • What's New
    • Our Blog
    • Our Podcast >
      • Soundcloud
      • iTunes
    • Press >
      • Latest News >
        • Hearings Board Rejects PSA Claims
        • Royal Dairy Sustainability Award
      • Press Statements
      • Press Reports >
        • Larry Stap on KOMO
        • Evergreen Press
        • Press Chinook Predation
        • Dairy Press Reports
        • Berry Crisis Reports
        • Media Reports (internal)
      • Fact Check >
        • Fact Check: WSJ on Dairies
      • KOMO report debunked
      • EPA Document Request
  • About
    • Q & A SFF
    • How You Can Help
    • Contact Our Representatives
    • Contact
    • Meet our Farmers
    • Farm Smart 1 Answers
  • CAFO Ruling Press